Social Mermaid
    Back to blog
    Reputation Management

    Review Management Best Practices

    Learn why businesses should stop removing reviews, when review filtering is acceptable, and how to practice white-hat review management.

    February 12, 20176 min readSocial Mermaid
    Review management high road visual guide

    Share this article

    Customer reviews are one of the most trusted signals people use when deciding whether to work with a business. That trust depends on honesty. When a company removes or filters too many reviews, potential customers often notice, and the business can lose credibility before the sales conversation ever starts.

    Why Your Business Needs to Stop Removing Reviews

    1) People can tell your business is filtering the reviews.

    68% of consumers trust reviews more when they see both good and bad scores, according to Econsultancy. Customers are more review savvy than ever and can spot when things look too good to be true. Reevoo research found that 95% of consumers suspect censorship or faked reviews when they do not see any bad scores.

    2) It looks fishy, like your business has something to hide.

    30% of consumers assume online reviews are fake if there are no negative reviews. BrightLocal also found that only 8% of consumers expect a business to have a 5-star rating before they will consider using it. If there are only five-star reviews on a review site, customers may assume the business is grooming reviews because it has something to hide.

    3) Reviews that are removed will only anger customers trying to share their experience.

    If your business does not allow or encourage reviews, customers who have something to say, good or bad, may find it odd that they cannot leave feedback. Customers can still leave reviews for unverified listings and profiles, so just because your business cannot see the bad reviews does not mean they do not exist.

    4) It looks like your business does not value customers enough to win them back.

    If your business does not allow feedback, it can appear that you do not really care about customers or value customer service. Customers like to see businesses that are open to feedback, especially businesses that listen closely enough to try to win customers back.

    5) It does not give your business an opportunity to win back trust.

    If a review is not published, it can be infuriating to customers. If your business did fail the customer, the review gives you a chance to respond, make the situation right, and possibly win them back. Because your response is public, other customers can also see that you care about how people are treated.

    6) Businesses miss out on valuable feedback to improve.

    While customers can sometimes have unrealistic expectations, many reviews provide helpful feedback about possible oversights. Oversights happen to the best of us, and there is always room for improvement.

    Situations When It Is Okay to Gate Reviews

    There are situations when it is acceptable for your business to filter out which reviews are published or to flag a review for removal.

    1) When the review contains graphic material or inappropriate language.

    If the review contains explicit language, graphic material, or inappropriate content, it is reasonable to flag it as inappropriate. Many review sites already monitor this type of content, but if they miss it, your business can report it.

    2) When reviews are irrelevant to your business.

    If a review does not mention or provide context about your business, products, or services, it may not be a true review. Sometimes customers leave reviews when they really want to ask a question. If it does not add meaningful customer context, it is acceptable to suppress or report it.

    3) When reviews are spammy or someone is plugging another business.

    If a review is unrelated to your business, is obviously spam, or is promoting another company, it should not remain published as a legitimate customer review. This can also happen when a reviewer mistakes your business for a direct competitor.

    4) When the review is fake or planted by a competitor.

    In the case of review fraud, it is acceptable to suppress, dispute, or remove the review. Unfortunately, reviews are sometimes used as blackmail, and this behavior is one reason why reputation management software and active review monitoring are so important. If you need help determining whether a review may be fake, tools like Review Skeptic, backed by research from Cornell University, can be helpful.

    Again, Please Do Not Review-Stuff

    Review-stuffing happens when a business owner or related party promotes the company as if they were an ordinary customer. These reviews often include unusually specific detail and may be much longer than a normal customer review. Many readers skim over them, and worse, they can make the business look less trustworthy.

    How Can Your Business Practice White-Hat Review Management?

    Here is a simple, ethical process your business can follow:

    • Provide exceptional customer experiences.
    • Ask customers to leave a review through in-store signs, surveys, email follow-ups, or direct requests.
    • Read and analyze each review.
    • Decide whether the review meets valid criteria to suppress, flag, or remove.
    • If the review clearly violates guidelines, remove or report it and document why.
    • If the review does not violate guidelines, keep it published.
    • Respond to the review.
    • If the review is positive, thank the customer for their feedback.
    • If the review is negative, try to move the conversation offline, remedy the situation, and win the customer back.

    White-Hat Review Management Visual Guide

    The high-road approach is simple: encourage honest feedback, evaluate reviews fairly, respond professionally, and only remove content when it clearly violates acceptable standards.

    Why It Is Best to Take the Review Management High Road

    At the end of the day, people can often tell when a business is grooming its reviews and only allowing overly positive feedback to appear. From a consumer perspective, it is better to see a healthy mix of reviews: mostly positive, with some negatives as well. As long as a business responds to customers and follows proper review management protocols, that openness can say more about the company than a perfect wall of five-star ratings ever could.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Should a business remove negative reviews?

    Generally no. Review platforms discourage it, customers notice when reviews disappear, and it removes the chance to win back trust in public.

    When is it acceptable to remove a review?

    When it contains graphic material or inappropriate language, is irrelevant to the business, is spam or advertising for another business, or is fake and planted by a competitor.

    What is white-hat review management?

    Earning reviews honestly: asking satisfied customers for feedback, responding to all of it, and fixing the problems that reviews surface, rather than filtering or stuffing them.

    Why should a business reply to negative reviews?

    Because the reply is public and read by everyone who follows, not just the reviewer. A calm, useful response does more for a business than a spotless record.

    What is review stuffing?

    Collecting a burst of reviews in a short window, or soliciting them in a way the platform forbids. It looks artificial, and both customers and platforms penalise it.

    Ready to simplify your marketing?

    Social Mermaid helps small businesses and agencies stay consistent across social, search, and content without adding more daily work.

    Talk with Social Mermaid
    Ready to become a Siren and attract more customers?

    Sing your brand's siren song and watch customers swim your way.

    Get a free business report and discover exactly where your siren can lure in more customers next.

    Contact Sales